There is no single way to generate climate evidence. Depending on the question being asked, the resources available, and how the information will be used, very different methodologies may be needed.
The new comparative report by the BASE Initiative, “Climate evidence for wildfire management in strategic biomes: Lessons learned from BASE studies in Amazonia and the Pantanal (Brazil) and Patagonia (Argentina)” (also, available in English), brings together lessons from two processes carried out in Brazil and Argentina. The analysis explores what types of evidence can be generated in different contexts and how they can support risk management, adaptation, and access to climate finance.
The two cases began with different questions. In Brazil, the process combined climate attribution and future projections to assess the extent to which anthropogenic climate change influenced the extreme wildfires of 2024 and how that risk could evolve in the future. In Northern Patagonia, the study focused on identifying how the meteorological conditions that determine wildfire danger have changed in recent years.
The comparison shows that these methodologies do not compete with one another: they generate complementary types of evidence and respond to different needs. Attribution studies can provide robust causal evidence and be particularly relevant to discussions on climate finance and loss and damage, while approaches based on trends and observed changes may be more accessible and more directly applicable to operational and territorial planning.
One of the report’s main lessons is that, before starting a climate evidence generation process, it is essential to clearly define why that evidence is being produced, which decisions it is intended to support, and what technical capacities and resources are available. Methodological sophistication alone does not guarantee greater impact.
The analysis also contributes lessons for BASE’s Climate Toolkit, developed to support professionals from different sectors in generating place-based climate knowledge that is both scientifically robust and useful for decision-making.
Read the full report at the following LINK. This report was prepared within the framework of the BASE Initiative, coordinated by Fundación Avina, with the support of Fundación Alimentaris, and includes contributions from Julia Mindlin, Santiago I. Hurtado, and Marcos H. Easdale.